top of page

What’s In The Stock Pot? A Celebration of Tradition, Culture, and Nourishment

  • Writer: capuanograce
    capuanograce
  • Jul 9
  • 5 min read

Opinion Essay:

By Grace Capuano


It is important to recognize that our histories, cultures, and traditions are not as far apart as they may seem. People making stock in the Americas were working in parallel with those in the Mediterranean. By pausing to notice these similarities, broth becomes something to celebrate across cultures and time periods, making it known that our practices are often more alike than different.



Broth is rarely made for one person, signaling the importance of togetherness that each pot can create. In a moment when food is often disconnected from its process, broth forces us to think about ingredients, as this simple delight carries so much flavor and history. Its connection draws together both sides of the stock pot. On one side is the person who woke up early to roast the bones, wash and chop the vegetables, gather the aromatics, and carry that heavy sixteen-quart stock pot from the sink to the stovetop to simmer all day. On the other side is everyone else, the pet, husband, wife, boyfriend, girlfriend, roommate, mother, grandmother - the list goes on - who gets to indulge in the cozy savor. What both sides share is the wonderful scent the pot emits all day, moving through the house like a gentle scented candle.

It is often a two-day affair in my house, starting with a trip to Adam’s Fairacre Farms to pick up local bones, vegetables, and a few extra snacks to get me through the day. The next morning, the alarm goes off around 7:30 a.m., and I leap out of bed knowing that soon, my nourishing, healing broth will quench my thirst for a sustaining elixir. 

In a world that feels increasingly divided, it is important to understand what connects us. As stated in You & I Eat the Same, “food can’t cure all the world’s ails, but it’s a start. If we can share a meal, maybe we can share a conversation, too” (Redzepi et.al, 2018). What broth looks like in my house, simmering short rib, oxtail, and sometimes chuck meat, looks different in households across the street and across the world. “Cuisine benefits greatly from difference—different ingredients growing in different places, different socioeconomic conditions, different historical influences, different people cooking” (Redzepi et.al, 2018). Soup is often a humble food, made from leftover bones, shells, and wilted vegetable scraps. In many kitchens, it relies on carcasses and trimmings from butchering, while in others, whole chickens, fish, or generous hunks of meat are used to create the very best stock. 

While the basis of broth-making techniques and ingredients are similar, soup style changes based on culture. Asians consume the most chicken soup (Fallon et. al, 2014). In China, bone broth is viewed as a healing elixir. In fact, nearly all chicken feet from American industrial poultry production is shipped to China, where they go into a pot to make soup (Fallon et. al, 2014). In Japan, it serves as the base of many dishes because of its umami flavor, in Korea, it is a hangover cure (Brodo, 2026). Mexican caldo is often served with rice, tortillas, and a splash of lime. Chicken soup has been described as “Jewish penicillin” first credited by Jewish philosopher and physician, Moses Maimonides, who gave it the stamp of nourishing approval in the 12th century (Fallon et. al, 2014).  

Broth appears repeatedly throughout recorded history as well. It is referenced as an offering in the Bible in Judges 6:19 and in the Shennong Bencaojing, a foundational text of Chinese medicine from first and second centuries AD, which explores the ancient process of boiling herbs and plants for medicinal purposes (Wu, 2018). De Re Coquinaria, the oldest known collection of Roman recipes, also mentions broth. Compiled over centuries beginning in the first century AD, this text is divided into multiple books, with the first, Epimeles, describing broths made from fish heads and herbs such as mint, thyme, pepper, and celery seed (Hill, 1936). Aristophanes, an ancient Greek comic playwright, also wrote about soup, mentioning it in his satirical play The Frogs, when Dionysus asks Hercules if he has “ever felt the sudden urge for soup,” to which Hercules replies, “Soup? Ten thousand times so far” (Fallon et al., 2014).

Boiling fragments of bones have been braided into human history for as long as 25,000 years, when archaeologists discovered distinctive cracks in rocks caused by expanding steam (Zielinski, 2013). These rocks are the remnants of stones once used to cook. Fist-sized stones were heated in fire and then moved into hide-lined pits or containers to boil water, or placed into dry pits to roast meat. Over time, the constant cycle of heating and cooling caused the stones to crack and split, breaking them into the fragments that remain (Benson, 2023). These remnants have been found near bison processing areas where Native Americans butchered animals, made hides, and boiled bones for bone grease or pemmican, a preserved, nutrient-dense survival food that did not require cooking (Ngapo et al., 2021; Benson, 2023). This history helps put into perspective how little separates us from people living twenty-five thousand years ago.

As broth has survived this long journey through time, its purpose has remained the same. Across centuries and cultures, broth has nourished bodies, stretched resources, and created warmth. From relying on heated stones, to the discovery of pottery, to a stainless steel stock pot, broth continues to provide nourishment while requiring patience and attention. The extraction of nutrients depends on long cooking times, emphasizing care as a necessary ingredient in creating something sustaining. Broth, stock, and bone broth are all made by simmering water with vegetables and aromatics, but they differ in time and ingredients. Broth typically cooks for up to two hours and may include meat. Stock simmers bones, sometimes with attached meat, for four to six hours. Bone broth uses roasted bones and cooks for up to twenty-four hours (Thomme, 2024).

Drinking this “liquid gold” provides collagen, gelatin, and minerals such as calcium, magnesium, and phosphorus, making it a solid source of protein. The amino acids glycine and arginine found in collagen offer anti-inflammatory benefits and may support joint health, muscle recovery, and wound healing (Thomme, 2024). Beyond its warmth and hydrating qualities, bone broth may also support overall bone health and serve as a gentle, nourishing option for those with low appetite or difficulty eating, including cancer patients experiencing nausea or mouth and throat soreness (Thomme, 2024).

Broth was often created out of necessity. From Indigenous communities using every part of the buffalo to Mediterranean cultures boiling fish heads for nourishment, broth has long been a resilient and essential practice. It reflects the value of leftovers, resourcefulness, and nutritional care that sustained people long before modern kitchens. Broth’s history is not about nostalgia. It is about recognizing the shared cultural experiences that continue to connect us.


References:


Benson, R. (2023).No Pots? No Pans? No Problem. Montana Earth Science Picture of the Week. https://formontana.net/boiling.html



Fallon, S., & Daniel, K. T. (2014). Nourishing broth : an old-fashioned remedy for the modern world (First edition). Grand Central Life & Style.


Hill, Walter. (1936). Epimeles: Book I. The Careful Experienced Cook. De Re Coquinaria. https://penelope.uchicago.edu/Thayer/E/Roman/Texts/Apicius/1*.html 


Ngapo, T., Champagne, C., Chilian, C., Dugan, M., Gariepy, S., Vahamani, P., Bilodeau, P. (2021, August). Pemmican, an endurance food: Past and present. Science Direct. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0309174021001029


Thomme, G. (2024, January 22). Is bone broth good for you? MD Anderson Cancer Center. https://www.mdanderson.org/cancerwise/is-bone-broth-good-for-you.h00-159694389.html


Wu, Q., Liang, X., (2018, April). Food therapy and medical diet therapy of Traditional Chinese Medicine. ScienceDirect. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2352939317300829#:~:text=Long%20before%2C%20plenty%20of%20monographs,and%20kidney)%20in%20ancient%20times.


Ying, C., & Redzepi, R. (2018). You and i eat the same : On the countless ways food and cooking connect us to one another (mad dispatches, volume 1). Artisan.


Zielinkski, S. (2013, February 6). Stone Age Stew? Soup Making May Be Older Than We'd Thought. NPR. https://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2013/02/06/171104410/stone-age-stew-soup-making-may-be-older-than-wed-thought


 
 
 

Comments

bottom of page